Strong Gravity

In January 2024, the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) mission was officially adopted by the European Space Agency, marking a new era in gravitational wave astronomy. LISA will be the first space-based gravitational wave detector, designed to explore the cosmos in the millihertz frequency range. This talk will present the mission's key scientific objectives and how the scientific community is preparing for the exploitation of LISA data. I will discuss the anticipated source types and the fundamental questions they could help answer. Then, we will focus on Extreme Mass Ratio Inspirals (EMRIs), a class of sources where small compact objects orbit the massive black holes at the centers of galaxies. These systems hold immense scientific potential for the LISA mission, as they encode a detailed map of the spacetime around the massive black hole. I will discuss how future detections of EMRIs can be used to constrain parameters related to accretion disks and modifications of General Relativity. Finally, I will highlight the path forward in preparing for LISA's launch and how to get involved in contributing to the mission scientific success. 

According to general relativity, the remnant of a binary black hole merger is a perturbed Kerr black hole. Perturbed Kerr black holes emit "ringdown" radiation which is well described by a superposition of damped exponentials ("quasinormal modes”), with frequencies and damping times that depend only on the mass and spin of the remnant. The observation of gravitational radiation emitted by black hole mergers might finally provide direct evidence of black holes, just like the 21 cm line identifies interstellar hydrogen. I will review the current status of this "black hole spectroscopy" program. I will focus on: (1) the role of nonlinearities in ringdown modeling, (2) the current observational status of black hole spectroscopy, and (3) future prospects for the observability of modified gravity effects and nonlinear modes.

The remnant of a binary black hole coalescence is a perturbed black hole, which equilibrates by emitting ringdown gravitational waves. These ringdown waves not only encode information in their frequencies about the spacetime structure of the remnant black hole metric, but also have imprints in their amplitudes of the progenitor black hole binary's properties. In this talk I will highlight recent results in black hole ringdown data analysis and new understanding of astrophysical ringdown amplitudes gleaned from numerical relativity simulations, and will then discuss how ringdown analyses may become a vital tool for making inferences of binary black hole properties - even in situations where the gravitational wave signal from the binary inspiral itself is never directly observed.

The groundbreaking detection of gravitational waves from merging black holes has forever changed how we observe the Universe. Upcoming detectors, like the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA), will unlock new opportunities by allowing us to detect mergers between stellar-mass black holes (tens of solar masses) and supermassive black holes (SMBHs, millions to billions of solar masses). These fascinating events, known as extreme-mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs), provide a wealth of information about the dynamics near SMBHs. A key formation channel for EMRIs involves weak gravitational interactions—two-body kicks—from surrounding stars and compact objects that gradually alter the small black hole's orbit, eventually driving it into the SMBH. However, the picture changes when we consider the presence of SMBH companions, which can induce high orbital eccentricities, further enhancing EMRI formation. In this talk, I will show that combining these two processes is crucial for understanding the progenitors of EMRIs. Moreover, I will demonstrate that SMBH binaries create EMRIs more efficiently than either process alone, making it truly rain black holes! This scenario results in a substantial stochastic gravitational wave background for future detectors like LISA. Finally, I will also discuss how this mechanism affects tidal disruption events and address the tantalizing question: Is it raining stars, too?

Black hole X-ray binaries and Active Galactic Nuclei transition through a series of accretion states in a well-defined order. During a state transition, the accretion flow changes from a hot geometrically thick accretion flow, emitting a power-law–like hard spectrum to a geometrically thin, cool accretion flow, producing black-body–like soft spectrum. The hard intermediate accretion state present in the midst of a state transition is thought to be associated with the presence of both a hot geometrically thick component, termed the corona, and a cool, geometrically thin component of the accretion flow. The details concerning the geometry of the disk in the hard intermediate state are not agreed upon and numerous models have been proposed: In the “truncated disk” model, the accretion flow is geometrically thick and hot close to the black hole, while the outer regions of the flow are geometrically thin and cool. There are many open questions concerning the nature of truncated accretion disks: Which mechanisms generate the truncated disk structure? What sets the radius at which the disk truncates? How is the corona formed and what is its geometry? In this talk I present the first high-resolution 3D General Relativistic Magneto-Hydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulation and radiative GRMHD simulation modelling the self-consistent formation of a truncated accretion disk around a black hole.

Observations of gravitational waves from binary black-hole mergers provide a unique testbed for General Relativity in the strong-field regime. To extract the most information, many gravitational-wave signals can be used in concert to place constraints on theories beyond General Relativity. Although these hierarchical inference methods have allowed for more informative tests, careful consideration is needed when working with astrophysical observations. Assumptions about the underlying astrophysical population and the detectability of possible deviations can influence hierarchical analyses, potentially biasing the results. In this talk, I will address these key assumptions and discuss their mitigation. Finally, I will demonstrate how we can leverage the astrophysical nature of gravitational-wave observations to our advantage to empirically bound the curvature dependence of extensions to General Relativity.

After reviewing the motivation and challenges connected with the dRGT theory of ghost-free massive gravity, we discuss our recent progress in understanding non-linear dynamics of this model. In spherical symmetry, numerical studies suggest the formation of naked singularities during gravitational collapse of matter. Analytically, the same can be seen in the limit where the graviton mass is much smaller than the scales of the matter present. Both of these results underline the need to move beyond spherical symmetry to try and obtain realistic predictions. To that end, we present a new ‘harmonic-inspired’ formulation of the minimal model and argue that it is well-posed, opening the door to full 3+1 numerical simulations. 

Maturing Pulsar Timing Arrays are expected to inaugurate the era of nano-hertz GW astronomy in the coming days under the auspices of the International Pulsar Timing Array. Implications of ongoing IPTA efforts for astrophysics and cosmology will be discussed while focussing on PTA contributions. Ongoing IPTA efforts should lead to persistent multi-messenger GW astronomy with massive BH binaries especially during the Square Kilometre Array era, and its implications will be discussed.

With upcoming LIGO runs and new projects like LSST and ULTRASAT, black hole (BH)-powered multi-messenger events will be at the forefront of astrophysics. A major challenge in studying BH-powered explosions is the vast dynamical range between the BH and the emission site, which has hindered theoretical models from capturing the underlying physics from observations. Using 3D neutrino-general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations, I will present the first such models, introducing an innovative model that now enables us to link GRB classes in mergers to their central engines and binary merger origins. For collapsing stars, I will demonstrate how our simulations open new frontiers in astrophysics, including a novel idea of how nascent BHs acquire their strong magnetic fields, heavy element nucleosynthesis in supernovae, the evolution of relativistic jets, new types of transients, and predictions of new vigorous, coherent, non-inspiral gravitational wave sources that may already be detectable by LIGO. These insights will be crucial for extracting the physics of transients from future gravitational wave and electromagnetic detections.